Week 6-• In what ways are school-age children assessed in other parts of the world? (Choose a country or region of the world for which you have a personal affinity.)
·
In what ways are
school-age children assessed in other parts of the world? (Choose a country or
region of the world for which you have a personal affinity.)
My Country is China
Title: Academic stress in Chinese
schools and a proposed preventive intervention program
The
authors suggested that while American educators fret about the mediocre
educational performance of American students in international contests (e.g.
the Program for International Student Assessment) and wonder why the Chinese
education system produces such high-achieving students, educators, journalists,
and public officials in China want to know what causes and how to prevent the
high levels of academic stress that Chinese students, their families, and their
school systems experience. They point the finger that the stress level has been
directed to the Gaokao, the Chinese national college entrance exam that takes
place in June each year. According to the article, they prepared a case for
strengthening bottom-up efforts at the school level in China and propose an
evidence-based approach for addressing the challenge of academic stress
experienced by Chinese students.
I have always wondered why the Chinese
students would reach higher educational goals then others around the world.
As stated, in 2010 and 2013, Shanghai
students twice topped the rankings for reading, math, and science in the OECD’s
international Program for International Student Assessment (PISA) Zhao, Selman
& Haste (2014). In recent response, American journalists, educators, and
academics debated the meaning of these PISA differences and searched
frantically for factors that may explain the huge success of Chinese (really
Shanghai) primary and secondary education as researched by the authors.
Although concerns about academic stress in
Chinese schools can be traced to the 1930s and 1950s, when China reopened its
doors to the outside world in the mid-1970s, Chinese education was lauded
internationally for its achievements in promoting universal schooling and
minimizing discrimination against the poor as further supported by the authors.
Finally, according to the authors they
briefly summarize the three most commonly held perspectives about the factors
that resist the pressures to change the educational culture: parental anxiety
over academic and job competition, teachers’ resistance to curriculum reform,
and the difficulty of reforming the gaokao system (2014).
Reference:
Zhao, X., Selman R., & Haste, H., (2014). Academic
stress in chinese schools and a proposed
preventive
intervention program. Journal Cogent
Education. Volume 2.
I have always wondered how China has created such high achieving students. Thank you for providing insight into that fact. I had no idea they had such a demanding entrance exam for college. I thought it was solely because of their core values and beliefs in the importance of education. Although that is a contributor, it makes sense that this standardized test that measures performance is also a big factor. However, as you mentioned that can come with stress on the children and the parents involved. How do you think this stress affects the performance of the children? Of the parents? How do you think both parties manage the stress associated with this pressure?
ReplyDeleteHeather: I think this is absolutely stressful for the child. As we reviewed the different videos this semester and the speaker spoke on how to care for our children from birth to 6 years of age, and this stress absolutely affects a child and will carry on into his/her life.
DeleteI do not think young people should have to endure this type of treatment.
Katrina
I always knew there was a lot of pressure on students in China because their academic rates are so high, but I never imagined things were this stressful for them. I don't think it's right that children have to deal with such high expectations from the get go. They don't really get eased into anything, having to be high achieving from the start. It's so stressful on the kids. The different mental health problems that can crop up due to the stress alone should be reason enough to not have such expectations placed on them.
ReplyDeleteHi Katrina,
ReplyDeleteThank you so much for the insightful information on China. Here I am going to share some info from China, which I got from my Chinese friend. Chinese students are facing tremendous pressure from the homework. They usually complete their homework by midnight. Chinese students are taking less than 8 hours of sleep; their appetite has gown down; they are tired; they can not concentrate for a more extended period; during the test, they are not doing well!
tasneem
I learned a lot reading your post. You sound very passionate about early childhood learning.
ReplyDeleteI just love it! I taught middle school, high school, elementary, and college but now I just love little people. Katrina
Delete